What's this game that we pretend to play
Always a day too late
Try and pick up that weight
If you want me to try I will
Try until you're satisfied
Promise if things go right
We can go back if you'd like

Stuck inbetween
Caught in the meantime
Always alone
Even the one time these feelings let me in

So it has to be just like you had imagined it'd be
With the rope in your one hand
Rock in the other
Swim for the shore
I don't belong
You don't belong here
Let's swim for the shore

Stuck inbetween
Caught in the meantime
Always alone
Even the one time these feelings let me in

When you were upset
I was screaming your name through the radio
Wouldn't I lie
Just to sing of your praise with hymns
When you were gone
I forgot how to make anything at all
You left before it was time to go
Mmm... Mmm...