Our hands touch as the record plays
You're the king of the clever phrase
My heart stalls as you call my name
You touch your hair and I do the same

We're both nervous that they're on to us
We have to be so obvious
And it's more than a little crush
All my words are rushed
And I'm feeling whoa

I can keep a secret if you can, whoa
And I can keep a secret if you can, whoa
Whoa

Our Eyes close as we cross the line
Your lips part and slowly move towards mine
My heart stops for the second time
A playful grin as you draw the blinds

We're both nervous that they're on to us
We have to be so obvious
And it's more than a little crush
All my words are rushed
And I'm feeling whoa

And I can keep a secret if you can, whoa
And I can keep a secret if you can, whoa

We never meant for this to end up like it did
We never wanted it, no we never wanted it
We never meant for this to end up like it did
We might have wanted it, yeah we wanted it

Yeah we wanted it
Yeah we wanted it

And I can keep a secret if you can, whoa
And I can keep a secret if you can, whoa
A midnight romance, oh